1. Start
  2. Artikel
  3. Mitglieder
    1. Letzte Aktivitäten
    2. Benutzer online
    3. Team
    4. Mitgliedersuche
  4. Forum
    1. Unerledigte Themen
  5. Galerie
    1. Alben
    2. Karte
  6. Speed-Rechner
  7. Surf-Wiki
    1. Letzte Änderungen
  8. Surf-Shop
  • Anmelden
  • Registrieren
  • Suche
Dieses Thema
  • Alles
  • Dieses Thema
  • Dieses Forum
  • Artikel
  • Forum
  • Galerie
  • Lexikon
  • Seiten
  • Erweiterte Suche
  1. Surf-Forum.com
  2. Forum
  3. Windsurf Tipps & Tricks
  4. Riggs

Camber oder No-Cam Slalom, AC-2 vs. AC-0

  • Totti-Amun
  • 25. Februar 2009 um 08:06
1. offizieller Beitrag
  • Totti-Amun
    Sail your own way
    Reaktionen
    14.290
    Punkte
    232.410
    Beiträge
    40.731
    Bilder
    11
    Einträge
    2
    Karteneintrag
    ja
    Boards
    Custom 130l, Starbord Kode
    Segel
    Severne
    Finnen
    Tectonics Maui, MB-Fins
    SUP
    Starboard GEN-R 14'0 x 27, Allstar 14'0 x 26
    Foil
    Starboard SuperFlyer
    Geburtstag
    30. Mai 1970 (56)
    • 25. Februar 2009 um 08:06
    • Offizieller Beitrag
    • #1

    Hier mal etwas interessantes für Einige, von Point-7. Zugegebenerweise herstellerlastig, aber den Inhalt kann man ja auch gut auf andere Marken reflektieren!

    Das AC-2 ist ein Slalom-Segel mit 2 Cambern, das AC-0 ein Slalomsegel ganz ohne Camber...

    Zitat von Point-7

    Camber or no-camber for your slalom?

    The normal perception we all have of sails without cambers against those with cambers is clear; With cambers we have more power and better stability, without cambers it’s lighter and easier in use.
    But is it really like this??

    Point-7 offers the AC-0 no-cam slalom and the AC-2 sports-racer a 2 camber sail; When put to the test how the real behaviour of these 2 sail groups? Keeping in mind that the characteristics of a sail reflects the development and intend of what a specific brand wanted from a specific sail line.

    As an example; we at Point-7 always target ourselves towards incorporating maximum performance in acceleration, top-speed, control and comfort into our sails. keeping these key points as our main objectives during the development phase of the slalom, freerace and freeride sails.
    For us it’s important knowing that our clients are the fastest on the water and that they have the control which will allow them to sail as hard as possible. It doesn’t matter if they sail with 4 cam race sail or a freeride sail, all the sails have been developed to meet our criteria.

    In the AC-0 and AC-2 the difference between the two sails is not limited to the obvious facts, further they definite themselves as a group to other 2-cam or no-cam slalom sails on the market.

    To prove this statement, we had the AC-0 slalom winning the Italian slalom Championship against cambered sails in 2006. It reached 43 knots during the speed run in Holland. The AC-2 recently received a great test result in the German Surf Magazine: Overtaking in top end performance all the 2 cam sails, having only one of the 3 cam keeping at its pace.

    Between the AC-0 and AC-2 the obvious differences between the 2 sail lines still remain; such as weight, change of tack and rigging of the sails.

    Weight: The structural weight of the 2 sails is similar. The AC-2 is not even 200grams heavier than the AC-0 . The only difference is the 2 cams and the extra material needed for the wider mast sleeve. The AC-2 is a bit heavier on the water during manoeuvres. The AC-0 has a mast sleeve much as on a wave sail, so less water than on the AC-2, gets into the mast sleeve when up-hauling or water starting with the sail. Both sail feel very light when sailing, due to the development made on the leach and sail profile….. even when the wind picks up to be totally overpowered. All power in the sails is transmitted into acceleration leaving the sail remain light and stabile.

    Rotation: The rotation of the AC-0 is as a wave sail presenting no difficulty. The rotation of the AC-2 is very soft and easy, but as with all cambered sails; its less forgiving and needs a bit more practice during manoeuvres.
    So if your jibing is not allowing for you to turn the sail at the right time, but you end up changing the sail too late; the cambers will still rotate, but it could mean that the manoeuvre becomes more difficult. If your jibing is average, you will not realize that the cambers are existing.

    Rigging: The new cambered sails allows the mast to be inserted in the mast sleeve, without placing the cambers immediately on the mast. This new rigging method has almost made it faster to rig a cambered sail than a no cam sail... only a little more technique is needed. (Easy to learn).


    Difference in performance:

    As stated earlier, these 2 sails are at the top of their class our performing their rivals.

    The AC-2 derives from the AC-1 development, the high-end race sail from Point-7. So it’s not just another classical freeride sail with the addition of 2 cambers, but a pure race machine with a couple of changes to make it more user friendly compared to the fully cambered sail.
    The leach opening and outline of the two sails are very similar, two reasons why the AC-2 have the same endless acceleration and speed like the fully cambered sail. Compared to the AC-1; the AC-2 has less luff curve, smaller mast sleeve, 2 battens less and a profile which is slightly deeper and further forward in the sail. These characteristics allows for the sail to be softer in pumping, being easier to control in chop, easier down hauling, more power in the light wind and better control of the board as gusts hits the sail.

    The AC-0 is a slalom sail; A no cam sail with high end performance, made specific to go fast and hold a lot of wind whilst keeping its stability. Made with 7 battens and not 6 as most of other freeride slalom sails on the market. The luff curve is like the cambered sails and the profile derives from same luff curve and not from the battens. Virtually meaning that the AC-0 and AC-2 has a sail body which is very similar in their construction. On land the AC-0 might appear very flat, but once the sail hits the wind, the mast is being bend away from the wind giving the sail its profile to the front: this profile is similar to the profile of the AC-1 ensuring a stability normally only found in race sails. The profile gives plenty power to the fin; having pressure on the fin is what makes the board accelerate and maintain a good speed! You‘ll be surprised how much wind this sail can handle and how the stability remains fixed from the lightest wind to the strongest gusts!

    Differences: The top speed of the 2 sails is very similar, turning it into a real war between the 2 sails. The power to get planning and the amount of wind they can hold it’s also very similar. The AC-2 takes advantage in keeping a high speed through the lows that could be found in very gusty locations. The AC-0 will be more forgiving in jibes. In case of extreme light winds the AC-0 is requesting a less technical pumping method than what is needed with the AC-2. The acceleration out of the jibe, could be faster on the AC-2, but if you jibing is not at a good level, this advantage might not be felt.


    The choice for between the 2 sails during purchase is very simple:
    Do you like cambers? = AC-2
    Do you hate cambers? = AC-0
    Do you like being fast, but your jibes are still not so good? = AC-0
    You jibe well and you might like to start racing = AC-2
    Can you race with the AC-0 and win? = Yes, and you can be faster out of the jibe from those who would have full cambered sails and a bad technique.
    Which sizes should you choose with 2 cam and those with no cam= You should choose according to what is explained above. Generally people tend to use the cambered sails for light wind and no cam slalom sails in stronger wind and for the smaller sails. That is also an option, but you should stick to the feeling you prefer and your technical level.

    Alles anzeigen

    Dateien

    AC-0-o-AC-2-2.webp 20,77 kB – 0 Downloads AC-0-o-AC-2-1.webp 67,05 kB – 0 Downloads AC-0-o-AC-2-3.webp 43,77 kB – 0 Downloads

    Dieser Text wurde nach alter, neuer und eigener Rechtschreibung geschrieben und ist daher fehlerfrei!
    Tipp Weltmeister F1 2011 & 2013, Tipp Team-Weltmeister F1 2009, 2010, 2011, 2017, 2019, 2020, 2021!

    Check out:
    Surf-Wiki.com
    Windcraft-Sports.de

    Verbrauch derzeit:
    810081.png, mit C253.
    595812.png, mit R107.
    896532.png, mit E28.

  • windsurfingtravis
    Anfänger
    Punkte
    50
    Beiträge
    10
    Karteneintrag
    nein
    • 26. Februar 2009 um 05:34
    • #2

    Wow...that is great! I made it through two pages of sales pitch BS and they arrive at this deep and meaning full conclusion...

    Zitat

    The choice for between the 2 sails during purchase is very simple:
    Do you like cambers? = AC-2
    Do you hate cambers? = AC-0

    I guess most of us had figured that part out years ago!

    Zitat

    Can you race with the AC-0 and win? = Yes, and you can be faster out of the jibe from those who would have full cambered sails and a bad technique.

    Yoh! I guess it all depends on whom you are competing against. If the rest of the crowd uses 4 or 5 cam race sails and knows how to use them I doubt that anyone would stand much of a chance with no cam recreational sail. Why would they otherwise bother making those TR 4’s and RS’s and Warps or what ever the stuff is called.

    Zitat

    no cam slalom sails

    Weird ! Sounds like a contradiction to me...


    Sorry, could not resist

  • olivombagsti
    FreiHeizSurfer
    Reaktionen
    1
    Punkte
    7.906
    Beiträge
    1.437
    Bilder
    26
    Karteneintrag
    ja
    Boards
    Exocet/Naish
    Segel
    Point-7 Ac-1 only
    Finnen
    Meanline/Lessacher
    • 26. Februar 2009 um 10:03
    • #3

    Hi Travis,

    but this guide is for normal people like me and you, if you are going to win the PWA I think you anyway have to choose a full Cambered sail.

    Jetzt mit Trimmtips, noch mehr Inhalt und Bildern
    :eek:

    Klick:49:

  • Dennis b
    Profi
    Reaktionen
    1
    Punkte
    3.276
    Beiträge
    640
    Karteneintrag
    ja
    Boards
    Various
    Segel
    Avanti Sails
    Finnen
    Z fins
    • 26. Februar 2009 um 16:44
    • #4
    Zitat von windsurfingtravis

    Wow...that is great! I made it through two pages of sales pitch BS and they arrive at this deep and meaning full conclusion...


    I guess most of us had figured that part out years ago!


    Yoh! I guess it all depends on whom you are competing against. If the rest of the crowd uses 4 or 5 cam race sails and knows how to use them I doubt that anyone would stand much of a chance with no cam recreational sail. Why would they otherwise bother making those TR 4’s and RS’s and Warps or what ever the stuff is called.

    Weird ! Sounds like a contradiction to me...


    Sorry, could not resist

    Alles anzeigen

    Guess you couldnt; the reason to write this bit was to make it clear what the difference is between a camber sail and a no camber sail which both belongs in the same class. Its a bit more than you have two pieces of plastic stuck in your sails which rest's on the mast..

    Anyway... BS can come from many directions :rolleyes:

    wazn

  • Dr. Pat520i
    Chef Analytiker!
    Reaktionen
    7
    Punkte
    27.762
    Beiträge
    5.403
    Karteneintrag
    ja
    Boards
    Starboard W44 & W54/ Starboard iSonic 97 & 114
    Segel
    Severne Reflex 7
    Finnen
    Z-Fins, C3, Tectonics, Hurricane, MXR, Meanline & Choco Fins
    • 26. Februar 2009 um 21:41
    • #5

    Hmm, interesting artical.

    But...I think it is much focussed on P7, okay, no problem. But in this case I cannot follow every point.

    For me the most important fact while comparing the AC-0 and AC-2 is the luff curve of the AC-0. For me it sound that they focused on the performace and you can see that in the luff curve, too. And not only in the artical, the profile was very impressive for me while I were seeing some pictures of the Ac-0, like a Race-Sail. (Interesting picture: Totti on the speedweek behind Dave White with a Gaastra Vapor)
    And now the AC-2, the base is the AC-1? Maybe, but as mentioned, they defused it, and another time look on the luff curve. Yeah, the same action you can find by other brands, for example North Sails with the Warp 2007 and the RAM F8. And yeah, the RAM was very fast and competitive (with 4Cams!). But how fast and competitive the sail is depends on the grad of defusing.

    And whats now. For me it is not suprising the AC-0 is so "strong". They focussed on the performace in every point without the Cams.

    And in this fact I don't think you can transfer this artical to many other brands, remind the 7 battens!

    But all in all, very interesting, because you can read many details!

  • Dennis b
    Profi
    Reaktionen
    1
    Punkte
    3.276
    Beiträge
    640
    Karteneintrag
    ja
    Boards
    Various
    Segel
    Avanti Sails
    Finnen
    Z fins
    • 26. Februar 2009 um 22:36
    • #6

    true Pat, the article is focusing on the 2 P7 sails.
    But what it does, is that it makes it very clear also what can be gained with cambers and what disadvantages they might give...
    Its information..

    Dennis

    wazn

Windcraft-Sports
AL360 Highend Booms
Patrik Diethelm Surfboards
Severne Sails
Sailloft Hamburg
Dunkerbeck-Eyewear
cool shoe corporation
Sportschule Innenhafen
  1. Datenschutzerklärung
  2. Impressum